1. **Absolute Bagels** — Upper West Side - Address: 2788 Broadway - Maps: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJm61vS4lYwokR-vM1u90mSME - Google Place ID: `ChIJm61vS4lYwokR-vM1u90mSME` - Price: $ - Best Time: Morning (expect a queue); weekday for shorter wait. - Access: Easy — Near Columbia University. - How To Get There Easily: Take the 1 train to 103rd St or 110th St. - Go If Visiting: American Museum of Natural History (same-area; before-poi or after-poi); Central Park (nearby-detour; same-afternoon) - Also Famous For: Thai-style iced coffee, mini bagels. - A no-frills, cash-only institution widely cited by locals as the city's finest bagel; the hand-rolled rings are boiled and baked in small batches, resulting in a thin, crackling crust and a chewy, airy interior that needs no toasting.
Bagel with a schmear · say “Bagel with lox and cream cheese” ·
Guide score ✕ verified reader stamps ✕ critic notes ✕ Google Maps signal. External reviews are linked, never copied.
·
1. **Absolute Bagels** — Upper West Side - Address: 2788 Broadway - Maps: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJm61vS4lYwokR-vM1u90mSME - Google Place ID: `ChIJm61vS4lYwokR-vM1u90mSME` - Price: $ - Best Time: Morning (expect a queue); weekday for shorter wait. - Access: Easy — Near Columbia University. - How To Get There Easily: Take the 1 train to 103rd St or 110th St. - Go If Visiting: American Museum of Natural History (same-area; before-poi or after-poi); Central Park (nearby-detour; same-afternoon) - Also Famous For: Thai-style iced coffee, mini bagels. - A no-frills, cash-only institution widely cited by locals as the city's finest bagel; the hand-rolled rings are boiled and baked in small batches, resulting in a thin, crackling crust and a chewy, airy interior that needs no toasting.
Order:
“A no-frills, cash-only institution widely cited by locals as the city's finest bagel; the hand-rolled rings are boiled and baked in small batches, resulting in a thin, crackling crust and a chewy, airy interior that needs no toasting.”
Queue: Near Columbia University.
Go: Morning (expect a queue); weekday for shorter wait.
Price: $
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: Operating since 1914, this is the definitive "appetizing" shop where lox and cream cheese are treated with religious reverence; the counter service is an art form, and their Gaspe Nova smoked salmon is the city’s undisputed gold standard. — Lower East Side
Queue: In the historic Lower East Side.
Go: Weekday morning to avoid the massive weekend tourist rush.
Price: $$$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A classic Midtown destination known for its large, hand-rolled bagels and extensive selection of flavored schmears; it is the quintessential "big NYC bagel" experience with a bustling, high-energy atmosphere. — Midtown East
Queue: Near Grand Central.
Go: Mid-morning; queues move fast but are always present.
Price: $$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: Consistently ranked as the best bagel in the five boroughs, this Queens staple uses a 1947-era recipe and a massive carousel oven to produce bagels with an unmatched malt-heavy crust and perfect density. — Whitestone (Queens)
Queue: Located in a residential part of Queens.
Go: Weekend morning (worth the trek).
Price: $
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A neighborhood favorite known for its warm, welcoming vibe and its creative, high-quality spreads; the bagels are hand-rolled and boiled on-site, perfectly suited for a slow breakfast in the park across the street. — East Village
Queue: Overlooking Tompkins Square Park.
Go: Afternoon for a shorter wait.
Price: $$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A Greenwich Village icon that for years famously refused to toast its bagels to preserve their integrity; while they have softened that rule, the quality of their hand-rolled, traditionally prepared rings remains elite. — Greenwich Village
Queue: Near NYU.
Go: Morning.
Price: $$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: The go-to spot for Midtown workers, prized for its speed and its massive, fluffy bagels that are consistently fresh and perfectly seasoned; the queue often stretches down the block but moves with machine-like efficiency. — Midtown
Queue: Near Penn Station.
Go: 07:30 before the Midtown office rush.
Price: $
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: While famous as the last great bialy bakery, Kossar's also produces some of the most traditional, malty bagels in the city; it is a vital link to the Lower East Side's Jewish culinary history. — Lower East Side
Queue: Near the Essex Market.
Go: Morning.
Price: $
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A modern take on the traditional appetizing shop that brings elite-quality smoked fish and hand-rolled bagels to Brooklyn; they are known for sourcing unique varieties of fish and creative, high-end sandwiches. — Cobble Hill
Queue: In the heart of Cobble Hill.
Go: Lunchtime.
Price: $$$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A massive, modern Brooklyn institution that specializes in a high-volume, high-quality experience; they are famous for their dense, oversized bagels and an incredible array of fresh vegetable and fish spreads. — Park Slope
Queue: Near Grand Army Plaza.
Go: Mid-morning.
Price: $
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: Founded after the owners realized Harlem lacked a world-class bagel shop, Bo's has quickly become one of the city's top-tier makers, offering traditional, smaller-scale bagels with a perfect, chewy texture. — Harlem
Queue: In Central Harlem.
Go: Weekday morning.
Price: $
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A modern hybrid that blends NYC tradition with Montreal-style techniques; the bagels are boiled in honey-water and finished in a wood-fired oven, resulting in a smaller, denser, and slightly sweeter ring. — Nolita
Queue: Near the shops of SoHo.
Go: Mid-morning.
Price: $$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: The world's most glamorous bagel experience; here, fresh bagels are brought out on wooden dowels and served as part of elaborate towers with some of the city's highest-quality smoked fish in a high-design, theatrical setting. — SoHo
Queue: In the heart of SoHo.
Go: Breakfast/Brunch (reservations required weeks in advance).
Price: $$$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: While often sought out for the photogenic rainbow bagels, Liberty is a serious maker that uses old-fashioned kettle-boiling and stone-oven baking to produce high-quality, traditional NYC bagels. — Midtown
Queue: Near Times Square.
Go: Afternoon for the "Rainbow" bagel photo op.
Price: $$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A rare bastion of tradition in the Financial District, providing the neighborhood with expertly hand-rolled bagels and high-quality smoked fish that rivals the best shops uptown. — Financial District
Queue: Near the Stock Exchange.
Go: Weekday morning before the market opens.
Price: $$
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A tiny, no-frills shop that is a favorite among purists for its smaller, denser, and incredibly chewy traditional bagels; they are one of the few places left that doesn't subscribe to the "massive bagel" trend. — Park Slope
Queue: On 7th Avenue in Brooklyn.
Go: Morning.
Price: $
Dietary:
Order:
Verdict: A reliable, high-quality chain that maintains traditional hand-rolling and kettle-boiling standards across its locations; it is one of the best "upscale" everyday bagel options in the city. — Midtown East
Queue: Near Grand Central.
Go: Morning.
Price: $$
Dietary:
0.0 / 10
17 stops
None known
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Best nearby foods: Signature order
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Challenges live in the app
Collect the dish stamp, submit proof, and earn XP from the mobile app after you choose a stop.
Have a dietary preference? We will surface relevant reports first.
Be the first to post a queue update or order tip in f/bagel-with-lox-cream-cheese.
Is the queue moving fast right now?