The guide’s ranking · Toronto

Best Butter Tart
in Toronto

Canada's most iconic sweet treat. A classic butter tart consists of a flaky pastry shell filled with a highly buttery, sugary, and slightly runny filling made from butter, sugar, syrup, and eggs. While the "raisins vs. no raisins" debate is eternal in Toronto, the city’s best tarts are judged by the flakiness of their crust and the "gooeyness" of their center.

Butter tart (English) · say “Butter Tart” ·

How this ranking works

Guide score ✕ verified reader stamps ✕ critic notes ✕ Google Maps signal. External reviews are linked, never copied.

What to order

·

Why locals care

Canada's most iconic sweet treat. A classic butter tart consists of a flaky pastry shell filled with a highly buttery, sugary, and slightly runny filling made from butter, sugar, syrup, and eggs. While the "raisins vs. no raisins" debate is eternal in Toronto, the city’s best tarts are judged by the flakiness of their crust and the "gooeyness" of their center.

Ranked Butter Tart stops in Toronto

Ba Noi

Order:

Stamp available
0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Saturday morning (they often sell out by noon).

Price: $

Dietary:

Google Maps

Circles & Squares

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Lunch hour.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

The Rolling Pin

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Afternoon.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Phipps Bakery Cafe

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Mid-morning coffee break.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Mabel’s Bakery

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Afternoon.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Tartistry

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Weekend lunch.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Bunner’s Bakeshop

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: While exploring Kensington.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Brodflour

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Morning.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Le Gourmand

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Afternoon.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

San Remo Bakery

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Early morning (lines can be 30+ minutes on weekends).

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Wanda’s Pie in the Sky

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Afternoon.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Brick Street Bakery

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: While walking through the Distillery District.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Sud Forno

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Lunch.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Rooster Coffee House

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Morning.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Bobette & Belle

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Afternoon.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

The Maid’s Cottage

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Afternoon.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Blackbird Baking Co.

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Morning.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Eh Bar

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Lunch.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Gerrard Street Bakery

Order:

0.00 stamped

Queue:

Go: Morning.

Price: $

Dietary:

Stamp availableGoogle Maps
Decide at a glance

Worth a meal slot?

Top score

0.0 / 10

Verified venues

19 stops

Per meal

Heads up

None known

Smaller context

Food near POIs

POI context is being curated for this dish.

Challenges live in the app

Collect the dish stamp, submit proof, and earn XP from the mobile app after you choose a stop.

Have a dietary preference? We will surface relevant reports first.

Be the first to post a queue update or order tip in f/butter-tart.

Is the queue moving fast right now?